Stargate Universe: Trial and Error


Stargate Universe - SGU season two wide banner

Welcome back Stargate Universe fans!

As with all my expositions, this contains full spoilers. syfy-logo-c2

Click to visit NBC Universal Studios

This week’s episode “Trial and Error” was written by Paul Mullie and directed once again by Andy Mikita. It had the great sense of suspense combined with some equal wonderful moments of humor that we love so much in the Stargate franchise. It also expanded the previous traditional since season 1 episode 1 of one-word episode titles.

Official MGM WebsiteIt had a lovely balance of action, suspense, drama, and humor. With the first run-through of the battle scenario, you thought it was actually occurring. During the second run-through, one might have thought Destiny was caught in some time-dilation loop similar to Stargate SG-1’s episode “Window of Opportunity” or Star Trek TNG’s episode “Cause and Effect.” However, the ultimate resolution was uniquely linked to Stargate Universe (Destiny) alone.

As the title infers, Colonel Young (Louis Ferreira) goes through mental trial-and-error processes as the Destiny syncs to his brain wavelengths, proposing different battle scenarios, as he spiral towards rock bottom. It was the perfect time to resolve the psychological toll of Young’s command. If it was stretched out any longer, the audience would have gotten frustrated (according to posts in fandom, they were already there). In our own world of great stressors, we often tune into TV to see heroes, people better than ourselves, characters we can look up when our own leaders are failing us. I do so love the dark tone of SGU, making the characters a little more real but also showing the consequences of decisions that are made, for better or worse. However, while one individual may be having a psychological breakdown on this show, there are many other heroes within the cast to whom one can look to for that role model.

SGU Trial and Error Young

Young still has lessons to learn. His marriage has failed because of a lack of communication of his intimate feelings which then led to his infidelity. Emily has filed for divorce, yet he still cannot communicate with TJ (Alaina Huffman) about his feelings of loss of his baby. From personal experience, my emotional journey through my grieving process after the death of my child was a much different one from my husband. It generally ends a marriage or makes it stronger. For us, it made ours stronger; for TJ and Young, the chasm could not be any bigger. This will solidify her draw towards Varro (Mike Dopud) who embraces both warrior and chivalry, a true knight.

SGU Varro and TJ

As I had hoped, Lt. Matthew Scott (Brian Jacob Smith) grew from the experiences in Cloverdale. He loves Chloe (Elyse Levesque) and will stand by her regardless of what is happening to her on a genetic level. Scott has grown a great deal since Air, Part 1, in terms of believing in the capacity of his own leadership skills. When Camile (MingNa) and Rush (Robert Carlyle) want him to step up into command, Scott instead heads straight for Young. Drawn perhaps to Scott’s priestly nature, Young confessed his sins of command. A nonjudgmental Scott listens and gives him a great speech that seems to finally get through to him, something that even General O’Neill (Richard Dean Anderson) was not able to accomplish. It was a great student-becomes-teacher moment and a highlight of this episode.

SGU Trial and Error Scott

Other highlights were the brotherly bonding between Eli (David Blue) and Greer (Jamil Walker Smith) and the love blossoming between Eli and Ginn (Julie McNiven). When Camile first brought Ginn to meet Eli, I am guessing, judging from her face, that she knew Ginn had a crush on Eli and could not resist an opportunity to bring some more happiness into Eli’s life.

SGU Trial and Error Camile

It was fun to see Greer and Eli planning some afternoon delight for Eli. Who helps Greer pull off this plan? Greer’s lover, Dr. Lisa Park (Jennifer Spence), calls Greer away so Eli and Ginn can be alone. When Eli gets cold feet and goes out for a pep talk from Greer, Ginn stumbles across the emotionally touching video from Eli about his mother. Ginn is thinking not only do I love his mathematical brilliance, but he also has an emotional depth that is so sexy.

SGU Trial and Error Greer and Eli

Inquiring minds want to know, Ms. McNiven? Are David Blue’s lips as soft as they appear to be when he was kissing you? Fan girls all over the world are awaiting your reply.

SGU Trial and Error Ginn and Eli


Later on, it is adorable again when the lines of business and casual blur for Eli, letting everyone in the room know that they may have a thing going on. I especially loved Dr. Park’s smile she flashed him.

SGU Trial and Error Dr. Park

As always, I appreciate that our other guest starring cast which includes Dr. Park, Dr. Adam Brody (Peter Kelamis) and Dr. Volker (Patrick Gilmore) are being given more dialogue lines. I am looking forward to seeing some back story on them some day, especially regarding Dr. Brody and Dr. Volker.

SGU Trial and Error Brody and Volker

Rush is al ways the voice that speaks the truth no matter how difficult it is to hear. When Chloe is in her room still quarantined from the rest of the crew, he reminds Chloe that there are advantages to what is happening to her, including the fact that she saved Matt’s life. Rush shares with her that he is closing in on what Destiny’s true mission was/is and thinks Chloe can help him by filling in the missing links.

SGU Trial and Error Rush

TJ takes the opportunity at Brody’s still to share her concern for Young and to talk to him about the baby. TJ shares her dream with Young. I thought this was an interesting writing parallel since Young was now also having dreams he felt were like they were actually happening to him (at this point, TJ did not know this). I wonder if this is just Destiny or if Destiny and the aliens from the “Faith” planet have a symbiotic relationship with each other? We are going to find out before the midpoint season finale.  She is hoping that perhaps this information will snap him out of his impending crash.

SGU Trial and Error TJ

This episode allowed Camile to play a leader once again. Distraught by his dreams, Young confides in her. This later helps to form a hypothesis that Destiny is communicating with Young. It appeared to me that Camile has gained some credibility in the eyes of Young as a leader, definitely representing the leader of the civilians versus Rush whom he still does not trust. They also believe that once Young resumes a commanding role, Destiny will jump back into FTL.

SGU Trial and Error Camile

Lt. Vanessa James (Julia Benson) beamed with pride seeing Colonel Young take his commanding role once again. She has a deep respect for her Young.

SGU Trial and Error James

It was also nice to see Becker (Jeffrey Bowyer-Chapman) once again, even if ever so brief. I’m happy to see that they are expanding his role as a soldier so he is not just molded into just a cook. He is a character of many talents: Chef, hairstylist, and warrior. Perhaps he would win Top Chef: Destiny and go on to take the double crown of Shear Genius.

SGU Trial and Error Becker

The viewer, however, finds out at the end that it was Rush who actually jumped the ship. For what exactly then was Destiny waiting? This question is formulated with the help of the apparition of Franklin (Mark Burgess).

SGU Trial and Error Franklin


My Favorite Visual Effects Shots

1. Scott getting blown out of the observation deck. And kudos to James Bamford and his stunt team for bringing us these wonderful stunt moments.

SGU Trial and Error Scott Blown Out

2. The Destiny blowing up.

SGU Trial and Error Destiny Blows Up

3. Brief return of the blueberry alien.

SGU Trial and Error Blueberry

4. Destiny in FTL.

SGU Trial and Error Destiny in FTL


My Favorite Lines

1. Young to TJ regarding his pending divorce: “Is it even legal to sign papers in someone else’s body?” (It continues to ask the moral and ethical parameters of the communication stones. Would that indeed hold up in a court of law? )

SGU Trial and Error Divorce

2. Greer to Eli in the mess hall (with regards to a potential relationship with Ginn): “Time to man-up.”

SGU Trial and Error Man UP Eli Greer

3. Brody on his Kino episode on Eli’s console: “Ancient toilets! Here we go!” (This better be on the BluRay extra content; inquiring minds really want to know).

SGU Trial and Error Ancient toilets

4. Greer to Eli (during the pep talk): “I guess I’m supposed to tell you to be yourself but in your case…”

SGU Trial and Error Eli Greer Pep talk


5. The Greer/Eli exchange during the pep talk:
Eli: “Okay, I’ve got this.”
Greer: “You’ve got this?”
Eli: “How long are you gonna be?”
Greer: “How long you gonna need?”
Eli shrugs.
Greer: “I’ll take my time.”

6. The whole Scott pep talk to Young.

SGU Trial and Error Scott Young pep talk

7. Park to Eli in the mess (with Ginn sitting there) when Eli thought it might be creepy that Destiny might be in his head: “Well what have you been dreaming about?” and Eli looks at Ginn and Ginn looks at Eli. So sweet.

SGU Trial and Error Eli and Ginn

Click to follow PBMom on Twitter!Looking forward to next week’s episode of Stargate Universe. Remember: We need to watch it live or live+same day. I know it being on Tuesday has made things very difficult with the popular shows it is up against on other channels, but decisions will be made regarding season 3 based on the first half of season 2. Let’s show our support for the franchise.

WormholeRiders. Click to visit & follow WHR on Twitter!Season 1 is always a get-out-the-kinks season; season 2 is solidifying itself as part of the Stargate franchise and not copying the Battlestar Galactica format.

It is worth a second look.  Spread the word throughout the land.  Leave a comment, or find me on Twitter or Facebook.  Thank you again for taking the time to read my point of view.

Hilda Bowen (PBMom)


2 thoughts on “Stargate Universe: Trial and Error

  1. as usual, awesome review. I enjoyed this episode and loved how u brought it back again. can’t wait for ur next one.

Comments are closed.

Next Post

You Never Know What Skill Might Get Useful - Sanctuary's S3x03 Bank Job Analysis

Tue Nov 9 , 2010
Hello from Sanctuary Team in Europe! So, it has been another week, another long wait filled with wondering what the new episode of Sanctuary is going to bring, what quotes will be the ones you will laugh at and remember for a long time… And finally the Friday is here […]

You May Like

error: Content is protected !!